Thursday, July 4, 2019

REQUEST for PROSECUTON Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson Violated Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a)

Eric W. Sporre
Special Agent in Charge
Federal Bureau of Investigation
5525 West Gray Street
Tampa, FL 33609

Rick Swearingen, Commissioner
Florida Department of Law Enforcement FDLE
2331 Phillips Road
Tallahassee, FL

RE: REQUEST for PROSECUTION Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson Violated Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a)

Gentlemen:

This is a referral for formal criminal charges against Judge Ann Melenda Craggs for violation of Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a) Criminal use of personal identification information; and related crimes together with Curtis Wilson, Esq., in the wrongful foreclosure of my Fla. residential homestead.

Judge Ann Melenda Craggs ("Judge Craggs") has presided over the foreclosure of my home in Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. v. Neil J. Gillespie, et al., Case No.: 2013-CA-00115, Marion County Circuit Court, Florida Fifth Judicial District, since August 18, 2016, after the recusal, sua sponte, of Judge Steven G. Rogers, see Doc-354 Order of Recusal, entered on August 17, 2016. The case commenced on January 9, 2013 in Marion County.

Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. ("RMS") is represented by Curtis Alan Wilson (Bar ID 77669) of McCalla, Raymer, Leibert, Pierce, LLC, 225 E. Robinson St. Suite 115, Orlando, FL 32801.

RMS is an active (as of today) Foreign Profit Corporation registered with the Florida Division of Corporations. The 2019 Foreign Profit Corporation Annual Report for RMS appears online, and shows the address for RMS: 14405 Walters Road, Suite 200, Houston, TX 77014.

RMS and its parent company Ditech Holding Corporation are in chapter 11 bankruptcy, consolidated case number 1:19-bk-10412 in the New York Southern Bankruptcy Court.

This referral is to both the MCSO and the OPD since either agency may have jurisdiction, as I understand, over crimes occurring July 18, 2017, in the Marion County Judicial Center, 110 NW 1st Ave., Ocala, FL 34475 during a non-jury trial where Judge Craggs entered a Final Judgment of Foreclosure that does not mention the arguments I made before becoming sick, or mention the fact that I was transported to the hospital before the trial ended, and left without anyone to represent me. Judge Craggs did not include any of my documents into evidence.

I am age 63. I am disabled with type 2 diabetes since 2006. Social Security determined I was totally disabled since 1992 following a traumatic brain injury as a survivor of a street robbery.

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson continue to rely upon the fruits of their crime in the wrongful foreclosure of my Florida residential homestead property located at 8092 SW 115th Loop, Ocala, Florida, 34481, Marion County.

The Plaintiff’s (RMS) state court in rem action alleges the 2009 death of Penelope Gillespie is grounds to foreclose a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage on my homestead residence, 8092 SW 115th Loop, Ocala, Marion County, Florida in a 55+ community called Oak Run. The property’s market value is $80,565 according to the MCPA (2018). I am one of three (3) borrowers, with my mother Penelope Gillespie, and brother Mark Gillespie.

A Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, or HECM, is a Federal Housing Administration (FHA) "reverse" mortgage program administered by the Secretary, United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (Secretary or HUD) to enable home owners over 62 years old access the subject home's equity. 12 U.S.C. § 1715z20 et seq. and 24 C.F.R. Part 206. The record shows substantial violations of the HECM rules by the HUD-approved lender and lender parties.

A HECM does not require a homeowner to make mortgage payments as a conventional
mortgage does. Instead, a HECM does not become due and payable until the last surviving
homeowner dies or no longer lives in the home. 12 U.S.C. § 1715-z20(j) Safeguard to prevent
displacement of homeowner. The HECM becomes due and payable in full "if a mortgagor dies
and the property is not the principal residence of at least one surviving mortgagor....and no other
mortgagor retains title to the property." 24 C.F.R. § 206.27(c).

I am one of two surviving HECM mortgagors, and the only surviving homeowner living in the home, alone, in substantial compliance with the HECM Note, making this foreclosure of a HECM premature. My bother Mark Gillespie of Fort Worth Texas is also a surviving borrower, but he does not live in the home. The HECM becomes due and payable in full "if a mortgagor dies and the property is not the principal residence of at least one surviving mortgagor....and no other mortgagor retains title to the property." 24 C.F.R. § 206.27(c). Mortgagor Ms. Gillespie died in 2009. But I am a surviving borrower or mortgagor living in the home as my principal residence, and retain title to the property. Therefore I dispute the Plaintiff’s allegations in its "Verified Complaint to Foreclose Home Equity Conversion Mortgage".

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson violated Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a)

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson violated Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a) Criminal use of personal identification information, used as trial evidence in the foreclosure.

Section 817.568(8)(a) states:
(8)(a) Any person who willfully and fraudulently uses, or possesses with intent to fraudulently use, personal identification information concerning a deceased individual or dissolved business entity commits the offense of fraudulent use or possession with intent to use personal identification information of a deceased individual or dissolved business entity, a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.
My mother, Penelope Gillespie, died on September 16, 2009. RMS alleged so in paragraph 5 of its Verified Complaint To Foreclose Home Equity Conversion Mortgage.

Penelope Gillespie was dead on July 18, 2017 when Mr. Wilson submitted trial evidence in violation of § 817.568(8)(a),
Notice of Default and Intent to Foreclose
Date Admitted As Evidence: 07/18/2017
Evidence ID: PL-4
because the Notice of Default and Intent to Foreclose is dated June 8, 2012 to "Penelope Gillespie" and "Dear Penelope Gillespie". The Evidence List appears at Exhibit 1. The Notice of Default and Intent to Foreclose appears at Exhibit 2 and is signed by Judge Craggs.

The Notice of Default and Intent to Foreclose does not inform "Penelope Gillespie" because she died on September 16, 2009. A deceased person cannot own property, or respond to this notice. This notice is defective.

A HECM foreclosure must commence within 6 months. 24 C.F.R. § 206.125(d)(1). Borrower Penelope Gillespie died September 16, 2009. The Plaintiff did not commence this foreclosure until January 9, 2013.

Because the Plaintiff missed the time to bring a foreclosure, it has relied on false documents showing Penelope Gillespie is still alive, including its notice of foreclosure, and routine correspondence addressed to "Penelope Gillespie".

The Plaintiff’s (RMS) envelope to the NOTICE OF DEFAULT AND INTENT TO
FORECLOSE (Exhibit 2) shows different names for U.S. Postal Service Certified Mail,
and is therefore fraudulent, because the Notice begins, "Dear Penelope Gillespie:" and not,
"Dear Neil J. Gillespie and Mark Gillespie as Co-Trustees of the Gillespie Family Living Trust Agreement dated February 10, 1997"
In fact the trust is not mentioned at all. Mark Gillespie was not provided a Notice of Default at his home in Fort Worth, Texas.

Therefore service on Neil J. Gillespie and Mark Gillespie, is fatally flawed. The Trust was not sued. Penelope Gillespie was not sued. The Estate of Penelope Gillespie was not sued.

On information and belief, the Plaintiff sued the wrong party in suing "Neil J.
Gillespie and Mark Gillespie as Co-Trustee of the Gillespie Family Living Trust
Agreement Dated February 10, 1997", see the Foreclosure Benchbook 2013 "Parties
to the Foreclosure Action", "Necessary and Proper Defendants" on page 16:
1. The owner of the fee simple title - only indispensable party defendant to
a foreclosure action. English v. Bankers Trust Co. of Calif., N.A., 895 So.
2d 1120, 1121 (Fla. 4th DCA 2005). Foreclosure is void if titleholder
omitted...
The titleholder on January 9, 2013 when the case was filed was the "Gillespie Family Living Trust Agreement Dated February 10, 1997". The Plaintiff failed to sue the only indispensable party. Therefore, the foreclosure is void. See Filing # 83954243 E-Filed 01/27/2019 11:53:01 PM
DEFENDANT NEIL J. GILLESPIE’S AMENDED VERIFIED MOTION TO VACATE FINAL JUDGMENT OF FORECLOSURE AND CANCEL MARCH 11, 2019 FORECLOSURE SALE
I demand Judge Craggs, and Mr. Wilson, be prosecuted for violation of § 817.568(8)(a), a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson also violated related laws, such as,
F.S. § 837.06 False official statements .—Whoever knowingly makes a false statement in writing with the intent to mislead a public servant in the performance of his or her official duty shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082 or s. 775.083. 
Mr. Wilson and Judge Craggs made false statements in writing to mislead the Marion County Clerk in the performance of his duties. Regarding Judge Craggs,
F.S. § 838.022 Official misconduct.—
(1) It is unlawful for a public servant or public contractor, to knowingly and intentionally obtain a benefit for any person or to cause unlawful harm to another, by:
(a) Falsifying, or causing another person to falsify, any official record or official document;
Judge Craggs knowingly and intentionally obtained a benefit (foreclosure) for any person (Mr. Wilson) or to cause unlawful harm to another (Neil J. Gillespie) by falsifying, or causing another person to falsify, any official record or official document;
F.S. § 839.13 Falsifying records.—
(1) Except as provided in subsection (2), if any judge, justice, mayor, alderman, clerk, sheriff, coroner, or other public officer, or employee or agent of or contractor with a public agency, or any person whatsoever, shall steal, embezzle, alter, corruptly withdraw, falsify or avoid any record, process, charter, gift, grant, conveyance, or contract, or any paper filed in any judicial proceeding in any court of this state, or shall knowingly and willfully take off, discharge or conceal any issue, forfeited recognizance, or other forfeiture, or other paper above mentioned, or shall forge, deface, or falsify any document or instrument recorded, or filed in any court, or any registry, acknowledgment, or certificate, or shall fraudulently alter, deface, or falsify any minutes, documents, books, or any proceedings whatever of or belonging to any public office within this state; or if any person shall cause or procure any of the offenses aforesaid to be committed, or be in anywise concerned therein, the person so offending shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082 or s. 775.083.
Chapter 825, Abuse, Neglect, And Exploitation Of Elderly Persons and Disabled Adults

I am an elderly person [825.101(4)] and a disabled adult as defined by Chapter 825.

Judge Craggs is a public officer who corruptly used her official position as judge to secure a special benefit (corrupt foreclosure) for Mr. Wilson.
F.S. § 112.313(6) Misuse of Public Position,
(6) MISUSE OF PUBLIC POSITION.—No public officer, employee of an agency, or local government attorney shall corruptly use or attempt to use his or her official position or any property or resource which may be within his or her trust, or perform his or her official duties, to secure a special privilege, benefit, or exemption for himself, herself, or others. This section shall not be construed to conflict with s. 104.31. 
Judge Craggs is a public servant as provided by the Fla. Const., Art. V, who violated her Oath of Office, see Art. II, sec 5(b).
(b) Each state and county officer, before entering upon the duties of the office, shall give bond as required by law, and shall swear or affirm:
"I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support, protect, and defend the Constitution and Government of the United States and of the State of Florida; that I am duly qualified to hold office under the Constitution of the state; and that I will well and faithfully perform the duties of   (title of office)   on which I am now about to enter. So help me God.",
and thereafter shall devote personal attention to the duties of the office, and continue in office until a successor qualifies.
Judge Craggs has committed other crimes in this foreclosure. I may submit those separately. But I may not, if the enclosed evidence and accusations are sufficient to arrest and convict Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson. The Bar and the Bench have worked since 2013 to confuse just about every issue in this case. I do not want to confuse this case further and thereby undermine any prosecutable crime(s) against Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson. Thank you.

Sincerely,
/s/
Neil J. Gillespie
8092 SW 115th Loop
Ocala, Florida 34481
neilgillespie@mfi.net
352-854-7807

Enclosures

RE: REQUEST for PROSECUTION Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson Violated Fla. Stat. § 817.568(8)(a)

Wednesday, July 3, 2019

Grand Theft Re Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson MCSO Ocala PD

Lt. Charles Welch
Sheriff Billy Woods                              Chief Greg Graham
Marion County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO) Ocala Police Department
wwoods@marionso.com                       ggraham@ocalapd.org
692 NW 30th Ave.                              402 S. Pine Ave.
Ocala, FL 34475                                 Ocala, FL 34471
VIA UPS No. 1Z64589FP294204688
Cc.: Timothy T. McCourt
Tmccourt@marionso.com




Lt. Charles Welch
South-Marion District Commander
cwelch@marionso.com
Marion County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO)
Southwest District
9048 SW State Rd. 200
Ocala, FL 34481
VIA UPS No. 1Z64589FP294292708

RE: Grand Theft Re Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson

This is a referral for formal criminal charges against Judge Ann Melenda Craggs for violation of Fla. Stat. § 812.014(1) and § 812.014 (2)(a)1 Grand Theft; and related crimes together with Curtis Wilson, Esq., in the wrongful foreclosure of my Fla. residential homestead.

COUNT I
GRAND THEFT - THE PROPERTY STOLEN IS VALUED AT $100,000 OR MORE
812.014(1) and § 812.014 (2)(a)1

The Grand Theft amounts to $105,401.75 through a fraudulent deficiency judgment.

Proof of Claim filed by Attorney Fisher, MRLP: $185,966.75 (see below)
Value of the property asserted by Attorney Noel, MRLP: $80,565 (see below)
Current projected deficiency judgment: $105,401.75 (see below)

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson warrant prosecution for violation of Fla. Stat. § 812.014(1) and § 812.014 (2)(a)1 grand theft in the first degree, punishable as a felony of the first degree, as provided in s. 775.082, s. 775.083, or s. 775.084.

The Office of David R. Ellspermann Marion County Clerk’s Office prepared an Evidence List for a non-jury trial July 18, 2017 that appears at Exhibit 1, in Case Number 13-CA-115, Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. vs. Neil J. Gillespie et al.

Evidence ID # PL-1 is Original Adjustable Rate Note (Home Equity Conversion). (Exhibit 2)

Original Adjustable Rate Note (Home Equity Conversion)
        13-CA-115-S
        Admitted Into Evidence As:
        Petitioner’s Exhibit 1
        Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
        Signed and dated 7/18/17 by Judge Craggs

Paragraph 10 of the Note states: (Exhibit 2)
10. OBLIGATIONS OF PERSONS UNDER THIS NOTE
If more than one person signs this Note, each person is fully obligated to keep all of the promises made in this Note. Lender may enforce its rights under this Note only through sale of the Property. (underline added) 
Evidence ID # PL-2 is an Adjustable Rate Home Equity Conversion Mortgage admitted as evidence on July 18, 2017. (Exhibit 3).
Adjustable Rate Home Equity Conversion Mortgage
13-CA-115-S
Admitted Into Evidence As:
Petitioner’s Exhibit 2
Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
Signed and dated 7/18/17 by Judge Craggs
Paragraph 10. No Deficiency Judgments, appears on page 4, and states:
10. No Deficiency Judgments. Borrower shall have no personal liability for payment of the debt secured by this Security Instrument. Lender may enforce the debt only through sale of the Property. Lender shall not be permitted to obtain a deficiency judgment against Borrower if the Security Instrument is foreclosed. If this Security Instrument is assigned to the Secretary upon demand by the Secretary, Borrower shall not be liable for any difference between the mortgage insurance benefits paid to Lender and the outstanding indebtedness, including accrued interest, owed by Borrower at the time of the assignment.
Foreclosure Prevention Options

A four (4) page document by Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc., titled "INFORMATION CONCERNING OPTIONS AVAILABLE ON YOUR FEDERALLY INSURED HOME EQUITY CONVERSION MORTGAGE appears at Exhibit 4, and online at this URL
https://myrmloan.com/Documents/ForeclosurePreventionOptions.pdf

Page 1 states, last paragraph:
Am I personally liable for amounts owed on the HECM?

HECM’s are non-recourse loans and you, and your heirs, will not be personally liable for the amounts owed. You and your heirs will not be pursued for any deficiency after foreclosure or after any short sale or 95% payoff that is completed in accordance with the rules, regulations and guidelines of the United States Department of Housing and Urban Development ("HUD").

Page 2 is titled,
What Options Are Available When the HECM loan becomes due and payable?

Page 3 states at paragraph (7):
(7) Walk Away. There is always the option of walking away and permitting the lender to foreclose. This is a non-recourse reverse mortgage loan and the borrower, the borrower’s estate and borrower’s heirs will not be pursued for a deficiency judgment after a foreclosure.

The Plaintiff’s VERIFIED COMPLAINT TO FORECLOSE HOME EQUITY CONVERSION MORTGAGE, 40 pages filed January 9, 2013, is available online, see the Marion County Clerk’s website at https://www.marioncountyclerk.org/

The "WHEREFORE" part of the verified complaint alleges at paragraph g, "WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Honorable Court grant judgment in its favor as follows: (pp 4-5)
g. Retain jurisdiction of this cause and the parties hereto to determine Plaintiffs entitlement to a deficiency judgment and the amount thereof; unless any Defendant personally liable shall have been discharged from liability under the subject Note pursuant to the provisions of the Bankruptcy Code 11. U.S.C. § 101, et. seq,.; and
I believe the "WHEREFORE" part of this verified complaint is meaningless because the Plaintiff failed to plead grounds or entitlement for a deficiency judgment.

Nonetheless, Judge Craggs found RMS entitled to a deficiency judgment as follows:

The Final Judgment of Foreclosure (Exhibit 5) states at paragraph 10,
10. The Court retains jurisdiction of this action to enter further Orders that are proper including, without limitation, writs of possession, deficiency judgments and re-foreclosure of omitted parties and to determine the amount of assessments due pursuant to Florida Statutes 718.116 or 720.3085, if applicable.
Chapter 13 Bankruptcy of Neil J. Gillespie Case No 3:19-bk-00808-JAF

Currently I am in Chapter 13 bankruptcy as a direct result of this reverse mortgage, Case No. 3:19-bk-00808-JAF, U.S. Bankruptcy Court, Middle District of Florida, Jacksonville Division.

Attorney Austin M Noel, Florida Bar No. 106539, McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC, represents creditor Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc., and filed two motions for relief from the automatic bankruptcy stays, one for me as Debtor (Doc 45) and one for Mark Gillespie (Doc 46).

Attorney Noel contends in each pleading:

          Paragraph 3, in part: "On July 18, 2017, a Final Judgment of Foreclosure was entered in the amount of $148,363.32." (Doc 45 and Doc 46)

Paragraph 5, in part: "The Debtor has no equity in the Property, as evidenced by the Marion County Property Appraiser’s value, which lists the value of the Property at $80,565.00," (Doc 45 and Doc 46)

Attorney Melbalynn Fisher of McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC filed a Proof of Claim for creditor Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. in the amount of $185,966.75. (Exhibit 6).

Therefore, using the amounts provided by Attorney Noel and Attorney Fisher, the amount of a deficiency judgment exceeds $100.000, calculated as follows:

Proof of Claim filed by Attorney Fisher, MRLP: $185,966.75
Value of the property asserted by Attorney Noel, MRLP: $80,565
Current projected deficiency judgment: $105,401.75

Background

Judge Ann Melenda Craggs ("Judge Craggs") has presided over the foreclosure of my home in Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. v. Neil J. Gillespie, et al., Case No.: 2013-CA-00115, Marion County Circuit Court, Florida Fifth Judicial District, since August 18, 2016, after the recusal, sua sponte, of Judge Steven G. Rogers, see Doc-354 Order of Recusal, entered on August 17, 2016. The case commenced on January 9, 2013 in Marion County.

Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. ("RMS") is represented by Curtis Alan Wilson (Bar ID 77669) of McCalla, Raymer, Leibert, Pierce, LLC, 225 E. Robinson St. Suite 115, Orlando, FL 32801.

RMS is an active (as of today) Foreign Profit Corporation registered with the Florida Division of Corporations. The 2019 Foreign Profit Corporation Annual Report for RMS appears online, and shows the address for RMS: 14405 Walters Road, Suite 200, Houston, TX 77014.

RMS and its parent company Ditech Holding Corporation are in chapter 11 bankruptcy, consolidated case number 1:19-bk-10412 in the New York Southern Bankruptcy Court.

I am age 63. I am disabled as determined by Social Security. Judge Craggs presided over a non-jury trial July 18, 2017 in the Marion County Judicial Center, 110 NW 1st Ave., Ocala, FL 34475. Judge Craggs entered a Final Judgment of Foreclosure that does not mention the arguments I made before becoming sick, or mention the fact that I was transported to the hospital before the trial ended, and left without anyone to represent me. Judge Craggs did not include any of my documents into evidence.

A Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, or HECM, is a Federal Housing Administration (FHA) "reverse" mortgage program administered by the Secretary, United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (Secretary or HUD) to enable home owners over 62 years old
access the subject home's equity. 12 U.S.C. § 1715z20 et seq. and 24 C.F.R. Part 206. A HECM does not require a homeowner to make mortgage payments as a conventional mortgage does. Instead, a HECM does not become due and payable until the last surviving homeowner dies or no longer lives in the home. 12 U.S.C. § 1715-z20(j) Safeguard to prevent displacement of homeowner. The HECM becomes due and payable in full "if a mortgagor dies and the property is not the principal residence of at least one surviving mortgagor....and no other mortgagor retains title to the property." 24 C.F.R. § 206.27(c).

Count II - F.S. § 837.06 False official statements

Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson also violated related laws, such as,

F.S. § 837.06 False official statements .—Whoever knowingly makes a false statement in writing with the intent to mislead a public servant in the performance of his or her official duty shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the second degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082 or s. 775.083.

Mr. Wilson and Judge Craggs made false statements in writing to mislead the Marion County Clerk in the performance of his duties. Regarding Judge Craggs,

Count III - F.S. § 838.022 Official misconduct

F.S. § 838.022 Official misconduct.—
(1) It is unlawful for a public servant or public contractor, to knowingly and intentionally obtain a benefit for any person or to cause unlawful harm to another, by:
(a) Falsifying, or causing another person to falsify, any official record or official document;

Judge Craggs knowingly and intentionally obtained a benefit (deficiency judgment) for any person (Mr. Wilson) or to cause unlawful harm to another (Neil J. Gillespie) by falsifying, or causing another person to falsify, any official record or official document;

Count IV - F.S. § 839.13 Falsifying records
F.S. § 839.13 Falsifying records.—
(1) Except as provided in subsection (2), if any judge, justice, mayor, alderman, clerk, sheriff, coroner, or other public officer, or employee or agent of or contractor with a public agency, or any person whatsoever, shall steal, embezzle, alter, corruptly withdraw, falsify or avoid any record, process, charter, gift, grant, conveyance, or contract, or any paper filed in any judicial proceeding in any court of this state, or shall knowingly and willfully take off, discharge or conceal any issue, forfeited recognizance, or other forfeiture, or other paper above mentioned, or shall forge, deface, or falsify any document or instrument recorded, or filed in any court, or any registry, acknowledgment, or certificate, or shall fraudulently alter, deface, or falsify any minutes, documents, books, or any proceedings whatever of or belonging to any public office within this state; or if any person shall cause or procure any of the offenses aforesaid to be committed, or be in anywise concerned therein, the person so offending shall be guilty of a misdemeanor of the first degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082 or s. 775.083.
Count V - Chapter 825, Abuse, Neglect, And Exploitation
Of Elderly Persons and Disabled Adults 

I am an elderly person [825.101(4)] and a disabled adult as defined by Chapter 825.

Count VI - F.S. § 112.313(6) Misuse of Public Position

Judge Craggs is a public officer who corruptly used her official position as judge to secure a special benefit (corrupt foreclosure) for Mr. Wilson.
F.S. § 112.313(6) Misuse of Public Position,
(6) MISUSE OF PUBLIC POSITION.—No public officer, employee of an agency, or local government attorney shall corruptly use or attempt to use his or her official position or any property or resource which may be within his or her trust, or perform his or her official duties, to secure a special privilege, benefit, or exemption for himself, herself, or others. This section shall not be construed to conflict with s. 104.31. 
Count VII - violated Oath of Office, Art. II, sec 5(b)

Judge Craggs is a public servant as provided by the Fla. Const., Art. V, who violated her Oath of Office, see Art. II, sec 5(b).
(b) Each state and county officer, before entering upon the duties of the office, shall give bond as required by law, and shall swear or affirm:
"I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support, protect, and defend the Constitution and Government of the United States and of the State of Florida; that I am duly qualified to hold office under the Constitution of the state; and that I will well and faithfully perform the duties of   (title of office)   on which I am now about to enter. So help me God.",
and thereafter shall devote personal attention to the duties of the office, and continue in office until a successor qualifies.

Count VIII - Art. II, Sec 8. Ethics in government.—A public office is a public trust.
The people shall have the right to secure and sustain that trust against abuse.

Note: The Judicial Qualifications Commission (JQC) has reviewed my complaints against Judge Craggs (Docket No. 16-561; Docket No. 19-032) and reached the same conclusion:
The Investigative Panel of the Commission has completed its review of your complaint in the above matter and has determined, at its most recent meeting, that the concerns you have expressed are not allegations involving a breach of the Code of Judicial Conduct warranting further action by the Commission but are matters for review through the normal court process. 
The purpose of the Commission is to determine the existence of judicial misconduct and disability as defined by the Constitution and the laws of the State of Florida. If such misconduct or disability is found, the Commission can recommend disciplinary action to the Florida Supreme Court. The Commission has found no basis for further action on your complaint that therefore has been dismissed.
Therefore, jurisdiction shifts to law enforcement for "review [trial] through the normal court process" as stated in the attached JQC close-out letters for Judge Craggs, because,
A public office is a public trust. The people shall have the right to secure and sustain that trust against abuse. - Art. II, Sec 8. Ethics in government.
Judge Craggs has committed other crimes in this foreclosure. I may submit those separately. But I may not, if the enclosed evidence and accusations are sufficient to arrest and convict Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson. The Bar and the Bench have worked since 2013 to confuse just about every issue in this case. I do not want to confuse this case further and thereby undermine any prosecutable crime(s) against Judge Craggs and Mr. Wilson. Thank you.

Sincerely,

Neil J. Gillespie
8092 SW 115th Loop
Ocala, Florida 34481
neilgillespie@mfi.net
352-854-7807

RE: Grand Theft Re Judge Ann Melinda Craggs and Mr. Wilson

Monday, July 1, 2019

Few people seek legal solutions to their justice problems, worldwide survey finds

Few people seek legal solutions to their justice problems, worldwide survey finds

ABA Journal Online
By Debra Cassens Weiss
June 27, 2019

About half of people surveyed from around the world said they experienced a recent civil legal problem, but most did not turn to lawyers and courts.

The study by the World Justice Project found that 49% of people experienced at least one legal problem in the past two years. Among the surveyed group, 29% sought any form of advice, and those who did preferred to turn to family or friends. Only 17% took their problem to an authority or third party to mediate or adjudicate their problem.

Only 29% of those with legal problems recognized that their issue was legal in nature.

Yet the legal problems had a big impact. Twenty-nine percent said they experienced physical or stress-related ill health as a result of the legal problem, while 23% said they lost their job or had to relocate.

The survey, available here, draws on data from a general population poll of more than 100,000 people in 101 countries, including the United States, in 2017 and 2018.

The survey found that the prevalence and severity of problems varies by country, but the most common problems relate to consumer issues, housing, and money and debt. Problems included disputes with landlords, neighbors, utilities, insurers and people providing professional services. Other problems included extortion from a gang or criminal organization, becoming homeless, and difficulty collecting money owed.

In the United States, 66% of those surveyed had experienced a legal problem in the past two years. The most commonly reported legal problems concerned consumer issues (reported by 30%), housing (31%), and money and debt (36%).

Thirty-three percent of those reporting legal problems in the United States were able to access help. Forty-nine percent sought advice from friends and family; 38% turned to a lawyer or professional advice service; and 15% got help from a court, government body or police.

Sixty-eight percent said they felt the process followed to resolve the problem was fair.

The World Justice Project describes itself as, an independent, multidisciplinary organization working to advance the rule of law worldwide. Elizabeth Andersen, WJP executive director, said in a press release that the findings are "a wake-up call to the legal profession and justice sector in rich and poor countries worldwide: Access to justice is a fundamental quality of life issue and our justice systems are failing people with often dire consequences." Read more

Saturday, June 8, 2019

$400K Is Now The Official Market Rate For Supreme Court Clerk Bonuses

$400K Is Now The Official Market Rate For Supreme Court Clerk Bonuses
Above The Law
By Staci Zaretsky
November 15, 2018

But not everyone is thrilled that the number has climbed so high.

Just how high will signing bonuses for Supreme Court clerks go? It was just last summer that the going the market rate rose to a new peak — $350,000 — but it’s now been confirmed that $400,000 is now the prevailing rate. Yes, you’re reading that correctly. Biglaw firms and prestigious boutiques are now willing to pay former Supreme Court clerks almost half a million dollars in bonus money just for signing on the dotted line, on top of their base salaries and regular bonuses. Former SCOTUS clerks are making almost double their Supreme bosses’ salaries. This is crazy.

We first hinted at this trend back in August, when my colleague David Lat mentioned that at least six firms — Jones Day, Kirkland & Ellis, Orrick, Paul Weiss, Skadden Arps, and Susman Godfrey — were offering $400,000 bonuses to their SCOTUS clerk recruits. Michael Scanlon, hiring partner at Gibson Dunn, now confirms that "the market appears to have settled" at $400K.

Court-watchers are having trouble believing Biglaw firms are willing to pay this much money just for a new associate’s résumé line, and some have even suggested that ethics rules be consulted. Tony Mauro of the National Law Journal has the details:
"It’s become absurd," said Todd Peppers, who has written books about Supreme Court clerks. "These firms can no longer credibly argue that they are compensating these former clerks for the additional education and training obtained during their Supreme Court clerkships. Yes, these former clerks are very smart. That being said, this is about access and insight into the individual chambers."
U.C. Hastings College of the Law professor Rory Little, himself a former clerk, said, "If I were a clerk today and knew that I could get an extra almost half-million dollars, I would feel very careful about the firms’ Supreme Court cases while clerking. Seriously, an ethics expert needs to look at this carefully, under the current ethics rules and concerns we adopt for lawyers and judges in other situations. All 37 clerks or more feel that same ‘tug,’ even if it is implicit or unconscious."
More clerks at one firm than at any other may be feeling that "tug" right now, and that’s because Jones Day just emerged victoriously from this year’s wooing of the SCOTUS clerks, having cornered the market after hiring 11 of them. That’s a $4.4 million investment in signing bonuses alone for a group of new hires who may wind up taking the money and running after just a few years at the firm.

As noted by Harvard Law School professor Richard Lazarus, "Jones Day is paying a lot of money for a photograph." Oof, Jones Day needs to open up a personal injury practice group for that sick burn. Luckily for the firm, there’s a pretty big chance it’ll be staffed by some highly intelligent Supreme Court clerks. Read more

Sunday, June 2, 2019

How the Law Is Used to Destroy Equality and Protect the Powerful: Noam Chomsky & Glenn Greenwald



The basis for power elite membership is institutional power, namely an influential position within a prominent private or public organization. Read more

Friday, May 31, 2019

Law firm is dropped from app's antitrust suit; Florida Bar fights request for hotline records

Law firm is dropped from app's antitrust suit; Florida Bar fights request for hotline records

ABA Journal Online
By Debra Cassens Weiss 
October 1, 2018

A ticket-fighting company that matches drivers with lawyers has dropped a law firm known as the Ticket Clinic from its antitrust lawsuit.

The plaintiff, TIKD, had targeted the Ticket Clinic for allegedly filing ethics complaints against lawyers who worked with TIKD. The Ticket Clinic defendants and TIKD sought dismissal in a joint stipulation filed last Thursday, and U.S. District Judge Marcia Cooke of Miami ordered dismissal the next day.

Lawyers for TIKD and the Ticket Clinic did not immediately reply to the ABA Journal’s questions about whether the suit has been settled, and whether the terms could be revealed.

TIKD has an app in which drivers who receive tickets upload them, pay TIKD a fixed price, receive information through the app about a lawyer to defend the tickets, and get a guarantee from TIKD that the tickets will cost no more money.

Another defendant, the Florida Bar, is accused in the suit of violating antitrust laws by investigating TIKD for the unlicensed practice of law. The suit also claimed the bar had given the false impression that working with TIKD would violate ethics rules.

The bar filed a Sept. 10 memorandum of law fighting a request to produce internal records regarding calls to its ethics hotline by Florida lawyers seeking guidance about working with TIKD. TIKD responded on Sept. 18 that the bar is equating its own confidentiality rules with an evidentiary privilege.

The bar had argued in a December motion to dismiss that it is immune from the antitrust complaint under the state action doctrine because it is an arm of the Florida Supreme Court and an agency of the state, Reuters previously reported. The U.S. Department of Justice filed a statement of interest in the case in March that said the bar does not have absolute immunity because of the Supreme Court’s decision in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. Federal Trade Commission. (Wikipedia)

The high court decision in the case held that a dental board made up primarily of practicing dentists lacked immunity when it sent cease-and-desist letters to nondentists who performed teeth-whitening services.

The Justice Department’s statement of interest said the Florida Bar can’t claim immunity unless it shows its conduct was in accord with "clearly articulated" state policy and the bar is "actively supervised" by the state, Bloomberg BNA reported in March. Read more

Judicial immunity protects judge who was recorded disparaging lawyers, 6th Circuit says

Judicial immunity protects judge who was recorded disparaging lawyers, 6th Circuit says

ABA Journal Online 
By Debra Cassens Weiss 
May 30, 2019

A Michigan state judge caught on a recording disparaging two lawyers has immunity in their suit alleging a conspiracy with opposing counsel, a federal appeals court has ruled.

The 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at Cincinnati ruled Tuesday that the actions of Judge Paul Hamre did not fit within either of two exceptions to judicial immunity. Hamre, who’s a judge in Van Buren County, announced his retirement from the bench a month after the May 2013 incident.

Hamre made the remarks at the end of a telephone status conference, according to the 6th Circuit opinion. The lawyers for the plaintiffs in a collection action, Donovan and Donald Visser, participated by phone, while the defense lawyers were in chambers with Hamre.

Donovan Visser is Donald Visser’s son, according to an August 2013 story by MLive.com. They represented a company called HLV that was seeking to collect a $600,000 debt from a storage trailer company.

At the end of the conference, one of the lawyers on the phone hung up, making a clicking noise. Hamre and the two defense lawyers in his chambers—Gary Stewart and Kelly Page—apparently thought all the other callers were off the line, Judge John Nalbandian wrote in his opinion for the 6th Circuit.

Two unidentified speakers in chambers used obscenities to describe Donovan and Donald Visser, and Hamre expressed agreement, according to the opinion. According to a later lawsuit filed by HLV, one speaker "called Donald Visser a f- - -ing d- -khead," and a speaker "called Donovan Visser a f- - -ing d- - -." Hamre agreed that "his son is even worse," the suit says.

Hamre also discussed the collection case, telling the defense attorneys that their client did not have to transfer all 600 trailers to the Vissers’ client as called for in an initial settlement agreement that was later amended.

At one point, Hamre’s assistant told the judge that she received a report from HLV detailing the status of the trailers, but Hamre told her to "throw it in the garbage." Hamre said he intended to tell HLV at an upcoming hearing that he was extending an injunction that favored the defense.

The 6th Circuit decision upholds Hamre’s dismissal from an HLV suit claiming a RICO conspiracy. HLV’s amended suit claimed that Page, Stewart and their law firm conspired with Hamre to violate HLV’s constitutional rights. The suit alleged that the defense lawyers and their firm gave Hamre office space and Florida vacations to influence his decisions, according to the 6th Circuit opinion.

Defendants named in the initial suit had called it "a study in defamation" that "reads less like a pleading filed in federal court than it does poorly written fiction," according to prior news coverage by MLive.com.

The only defendant who wasn’t dismissed from HLV’s suit was Stewart. Jurors found a conspiracy but awarded only $1 in nominal damages. Jurors did not award punitive damages because they found that Stewart’s conduct was not motivated by evil motive and did not reflect indifference to the plaintiffs’ due process rights.

The 6th Circuit decision affirming Hamre’s dismissal from the case also upheld rulings by the trial judge challenged by HLV.

The Michigan Attorney Discipline Board affirmed reprimands for Stewart, Page and Hamre in July 2017. Read more

Hat tip to Law360.

Tuesday, May 28, 2019

SCOTUS denies cert in case on pro se treatment filed by David Boies and Richard Posner

SCOTUS denies cert in case on pro se treatment filed by David Boies and Richard Posner

American Bar Association
By Debra Cassens Weiss
April 30, 2019

A former pro se litigant had some high-powered help when he asked the U.S. Supreme Court to consider what kind of explanation courts must provide to unrepresented people.

Among those representing litigant William Bond were former Circuit Judge Richard Posner and Boies Schiller Flexner chair David Boies. The U.S. Supreme Court nonetheless denied cert Monday.

Bond had accused three federal judges of conspiring to throw a case. A federal judge had tossed Bond’s lawsuit and denied two motions seeking to amend it. After Posner took up the case, the 4th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at in Richmond, Virginia, ruled that the federal court did not abuse its discretion by denying the second motion.

The cert petition identifies the issue as whether a district court must provide a reason when denying a pro se litigant leave to amend a complaint when the reason can be gleaned from the litigation record. The district court order denying Bond’s second motion to amend had said it was based on reasons stated in an initial dismissal of the suit.

The cert petition had argued that the order didn’t provide an adequate explanation. "Absent notice of their pleading deficiencies," the cert petition said, "very few pro se litigants can parse the record and identify how to successfully amend their complaints."

Posner had abruptly retired from the 7th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals at Chicago in 2017, citing boredom with judging and rebuffed efforts to aid pro se litigants. He went on to form a nationwide pro bono group to help pro se litigants. Read more

Saturday, January 12, 2019

US Supreme Court petitions, reverse mortgage foreclosure















UPDATE for January 12, 2019

Dec 10 2018     Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. Docketed: January 3, 2019 (Response due February 4, 2019)

USSC Petition No. 18-7225 Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd list)

Petition No. 18-7225 Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd)

Friday, October 5, 2018

US Supreme Court petitions, reverse mortgage foreclosure















UPDATE for October 5, 2018

Oct 05 2018 Application (18A352) granted by Justice Thomas extending the time to file until December 10, 2018.

Oct 01 2018 Application (18A352) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from October 11, 2018 to December 10, 2018, submitted to Justice Thomas.

USSC Application No. 18A352 Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. (Scribd list)

Application to Justice Thomas Rule 13.5 to Extend Time to File Petition (Scribd)

APPENDIX A Petitioner’s Amended Motion for Reinstatement FSC18-343 (Scribd)
APPENDIX B Occupancy Permitted for Petitioner’s Home (Scribd)
APPENDIX C Affidavit of Neil J. Gillespie Re Non-jury Trial July 18, 2017 (Scribd)
___________________________________________________________

UPDATE for October 1, 2018

My petition for rehearing in No. 17-8689 was DENIED on October 1, 2018.
___________________________________________________________

UPDATE for July 20, 2018

My petition for rehearing in No. 17-8689 was filed on July 20, 2018.

USSC Docket for 17-8689 (Supreme Court of Florida Case # SC17-1361)
Title: Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner. Petition for rehearing filed July 20, 2018

USSC No. 17-8689 PETITION FOR REHEARING (Scribd List)

Appendix A, US Sen. Nelson o NJG on Separation of Powers Re USSC Petitions May-21-2018
                     With Attachments

Appendix B, Gillespie letter to AO Director James C. Duff

Appendix C, Petitioner’s Amended Motion for Reinstatement
                    Florida Supreme Court Case No. SC18-343

Appendix D, Petitioner Gillespie’s Verified Rule 1.540 Motion to Vacate Final Order
                    Florida Supreme Court Case No. SC17-1321

Appendix E, Notice of Filing Affidavit of Neil J. Gillespie Non-Jury Trial Jul-18-2017
                    Marion County Florida Case No. 2013-CA-000115

Appendix F, Defendant Neil j. Gillespie's Verified Notice to Clerk Ellspermann the Clerk’s
                   Foreclosure Evidence List is Wrong
                   Marion County Florida Case No. 2013-CA-000115

Appendix G, Petition No. 12-7747 for Writ of Certiorari SCOTUS

Appendix G, Petition No. 12-7747 Index and Rule Applications

Appendix G, US Supreme Court Clerk's reply letter Mr Higgins Oct-19-2016

Appendix H, Petition For Writ of Mandamus FSC 2016-2031
___________________________________________________________

UPDATE for June 25, 2018

On June 25, 2018 the Court entered the following order in No. 17-8682 and No. 17-8689:
The motion of petitioner for leave to proceed in forma pauperis is denied, and the petition for a writ of certiorari is dismissed. See Rule 39.8.

Posted May 17, 2017

The Supreme Court of the United States has docketed two new petitions for writ of certiorari in the wrongful foreclosure of my home on a Home Equity Conversion Mortgage, also called a HECM reverse mortgage, No. 17-8682 and No. 17-8689.
Trial Court, Marion County Florida Circuit Civil, Case No. 2013-CA-000115
Reverse Mortgage Solutions, Inc. v. Neil J. Gillespie, et al.
http://www.marioncountyclerk.org/
42-2013CA000115-CAAXXX [13CA000115AX]
Circuit Judge Ann Melinda Craggs (Aug-17-2016 to present) 
Circuit Judge Steven G. Rogers (May-10-2016 to Aug-17-2016)
Circuit Judge Jennifer Bass (Jan-01-2016 to May-10-2016)
Circuit Judge Hale Ralph Stancil (Jan-09-2013 to Dec-31-2015)
Previous USSC petitions:

USSC Petition No. 17-7053, Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd List)
USSC Petition No. 17-7054, Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd List)
USSC Petition No. 13-7280, Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd List)
USSC Petition No. 12-7747, Gillespie v Thirteenth Judicial Circuit, FL (Scribd List)
___________________________________________________________

Petition No. 17-8682

USSC Docket for 17-8682 (Supreme Court of Florida Case #SC18-116)
Title: Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner. Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due May 29, 2018) Party name: Neil Gillespie

USSC Petition No. 17-8682 Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd List)

USSC Petition No. 17-8682 (Petition only, Scribd)
Appendix 1, APPELLANT’S NOTICE OF APPEAL FSC18-116
Appendix 2, TFB 2014-30,525 (9A) Florida Bar complaint Danielle N Parsons
Appendix 3, TFB File No. 2017-1020(17C) UPL Investigation of Stephen Michael Allgood
Appendix 4, TFB File No. 2017-30,550 (9D) Florida Bar Complaint Curtis Allen Wilson

Gillespie Email to Supreme Court of the United States Apr-30-2018
RE: Petition for writ of certiorari in FSC17-1361, Neil J. Gillespie v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Linked with Application No. 17A878
RE: Petition for writ of certiorari in FSC18-116, Neil J. Gillespie v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions

Waiver to Respond by Curtis Wilson, McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC, USSC No. 17-8682

 ___________________________________________________________


Petition No. 17-8689

USSC Docket for 17-8689 (Supreme Court of Florida Case # SC17-1361)
Title: Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Neil J. Gillespie, Petitioner. Petition for a writ of certiorari and motion for leave to proceed in forma pauperis filed. (Response due May 30, 2018) Party name: Neil Gillespie

USSC Petition No. 17-8689 Gillespie v Reverse Mortgage Solutions (Scribd List)

USSC Petition No. 17-8689 (Petition only, Scribd)

Appendix A, FSC17-1361 Petition for Writ of Prohibition Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
SUPREME COURT OF FLORIDA Case No. SC17-1361
Filing # 59259445 E-Filed 07/19/2017 08:05:57 PM
Petition for Writ of Prohibition - A Case of Original Jurisdiction
To Remove Marion County Circuit Court Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
Appendix B, 5D17-2317 Petition for Writ of Prohibition Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
Florida 5th District Court of Appeals Case No. 5D17-2317, RECEIVED,
7/21/2017, 11:50 AM, Joanne P. Simmons, Fifth District Court of Appeal
Petition for Writ of Prohibition - A Case of Original Jurisdiction
To Remove Marion County Circuit Court Judge Ann Melinda Craggs
Appendix C, Notice of Criminal Complaint to FBI Special Agent In Charge Sporre

Appendix D, Third Verified Motion to Disqualify Circuit Judge Ann Melida Craggs

Appendix E, Denial of Adult Protective Services for Neil J. Gillespie, vulnerable adult, age 61, and a person with disabilities, by Robert Anderson, State Director, Adult Protective Services;

  • 415.1034 Mandatory reporting death of Frank Collelo
Appendix F, U.S. Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 13-11595-B, Composite

  • District Court Docket No: 5:13-cv-00058-WTH-PRL
  • Gillespie letter to Hon. Ed Carnes, Chief Judge 11th COA; Response
  • ORDER July 25, 2013, in relevant part, "Should Gillespie wish to petition for mandamus relief, he may file a separate petition for writ of mandamus or prohibition with this Court. See 18 U.S.C. § 1651; Fed.R.App.P.21" Before: HULL, WILSON and JORDAN
  • MOTION TO RECONSIDER, VACATE OR MODIFY ORDER
Appendix G, NOTICE OF FILING FEDERAL CIVIL RIGHTS COMPLAINT
                     U.S. Department of Justice, Civil Rights Division, Voting Section

Gillespie Email to Supreme Court of the United States Apr-30-2018
RE: Petition for writ of certiorari in FSC17-1361, Neil J. Gillespie v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Linked with Application No. 17A878
RE: Petition for writ of certiorari in FSC18-116, Neil J. Gillespie v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions

Gillespie Email to McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC May-08-2018
RE: Petition for writ of certiorari in FSC17-1361, Neil J. Gillespie v. Reverse Mortgage Solutions
Linked with Application No. 17A878
Waiver to Respond by Curtis Wilson, McCalla Raymer Leibert Pierce, LLC, USSC No. 17-8689


___________________________________________________________

Blog UPDATED APRIL 16, 2018, US Supreme Court petitions, reverse mortgage foreclosure

___________________________________________________________

Reverse Mortgage Daily: Florida Court Rules in Favor of Bank in Non-Borrowing Spouse Case

OneWest Bank, FSB v. Palmero (3rdDCA docket)
Case No. 3D14-3114 (OPINION Legal.com)
OneWest Bank, FSB, Appellant, v. Luisa Palmero, et al., Appellees
District Court of Appeal of Florida, Third District
Opinion filed April 18, 2018
Before EMAS, LOGUE and LUCK, JJ.

Lower Tribunal Case(s):10-3055
Final Civil Other Notice from Dade County
http://www.miami-dadeclerk.com/

___________________________________________________________

Monday, June 18, 2018

Senate Judiciary Committee chair Grassley suggests judiciary needs an inspector general

Chuck Grassley
Senate Judiciary Committee chair Grassley suggests judiciary needs an inspector general

ABA Journal Daily News
By Debra Cassens Weiss
June 15, 2018


Senate Judiciary Committee chairman Chuck Grassley said Wednesday that it may be time for an independent inspector general to handle misconduct complaints against the federal judiciary.

Speaking at a committee hearing, Grassley said nearly every federal agency has a watchdog that can guard against misconduct, report the National Law Journal and CNN. "It’s time for the federal judiciary to catch up," he said. Bloomberg Big Law Business and the Huffington Post also have coverage of the hearing.

Judicial officials have taken the position that an inspector general isn’t needed, and could violate separation of powers principles, according to CNN.

Grassley criticized a recent report by a federal court working group that said the judiciary should revise codes of conduct to promote appropriate behavior. The report also said judges have a special responsibility to promote appropriate behavior and report misconduct by others, including other judges.

Grassley said in a June 5 statement that the report "kicks the can down the road" and leaves specific policy changes to other committees.

At Wednesday’s hearing, James Duff, the director of the Administrative Office of the U.S. Courts, said the judiciary has a process that works when it’s used. The problem, he said, it that some misconduct might go unreported because employees find the process to be too complicated, they don’t know about it or they fear retaliation.

The working group was formed at the request of Chief Justice John G. Roberts Jr. after 15 women accused Judge Alex Kozinski of misconduct in interviews with the Washington Post. Kozinski, a judge on the San Francisco-based 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, announced his immediate retirement in December. Read more